Thursday, 19 November 2026

Lord MacLean obituary: last-surviving Lockerbie trial judge

 [This is the headline over an obituary in today's edition of The Times. It reads in part:]

Lord MacLean had the distinction of presiding, with two other judges, over one of the most unique and controversial trials in Scottish legal history — that of the two Libyans accused of bombing Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie in 1988, killing 270 people.


It was unique because the court sat not in Scotland, but at Camp Zeist, a disused US air base in the Netherlands that was effectively deemed to be part of Scotland for the duration of the trial. Libya’s Colonel Gaddafi had refused to let the two men stand trial in Scotland itself, so Camp Zeist was a compromise. It was controversial because while MacLean and his colleagues, Lord Sutherland and Lord Coulsfield, acquitted one of the two men after the 36-week, jury-less trial in 2001, it found the other, Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, guilty and sentenced him to life imprisonment.


Megrahi, who was allegedly a Libyan intelligence officer, subsequently lost his appeal. He was granted a fresh appeal by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission after a four-year review of his case, but dropped the second appeal in 2009 when he was allowed to return to Libya from his Glasgow prison because he was deemed to have terminal cancer.


Megrahi always protested his innocence, which was not surprising, but other interested parties also questioned his conviction. Robert Black, the University of Edinburgh law professor who had devised the Camp Zeist compromise, called it “the most disgraceful miscarriage of justice in Scotland for 100 years”, and suggested the three judges had been “consciously or unconsciously” under pressure to convict.


Professor Hans Köchler, who attended the trial as an official UN observer, said it was tainted by international power politics. Jim Swire, a spokesman for the victims’ families who lost his daughter in the bombing, said he believed Megrahi was innocent, commenting: “Those who have studied (the trial) really find it impossible to maintain faith in the verdict.” Even Lord Fraser of Carmyllie, the Scottish lord advocate who indicted Megrahi, cast doubt on the reliability of the main witness, a Maltese shopkeeper named Tony Gauci. But MacLean, the last survivor of the three-judge panel, never expressed any second thoughts — not even within the privacy of his family. “I have no doubt, on the evidence we heard, that the judgments we made and the verdicts we reached were correct,” he insisted.

No comments:

Post a Comment