Thursday, 19 November 2026

Lord MacLean obituary: last-surviving Lockerbie trial judge

 [This is the headline over an obituary in today's edition of The Times. It reads in part:]

Lord MacLean had the distinction of presiding, with two other judges, over one of the most unique and controversial trials in Scottish legal history — that of the two Libyans accused of bombing Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie in 1988, killing 270 people.


It was unique because the court sat not in Scotland, but at Camp Zeist, a disused US air base in the Netherlands that was effectively deemed to be part of Scotland for the duration of the trial. Libya’s Colonel Gaddafi had refused to let the two men stand trial in Scotland itself, so Camp Zeist was a compromise. It was controversial because while MacLean and his colleagues, Lord Sutherland and Lord Coulsfield, acquitted one of the two men after the 36-week, jury-less trial in 2001, it found the other, Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, guilty and sentenced him to life imprisonment.


Megrahi, who was allegedly a Libyan intelligence officer, subsequently lost his appeal. He was granted a fresh appeal by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission after a four-year review of his case, but dropped the second appeal in 2009 when he was allowed to return to Libya from his Glasgow prison because he was deemed to have terminal cancer.


Megrahi always protested his innocence, which was not surprising, but other interested parties also questioned his conviction. Robert Black, the University of Edinburgh law professor who had devised the Camp Zeist compromise, called it “the most disgraceful miscarriage of justice in Scotland for 100 years”, and suggested the three judges had been “consciously or unconsciously” under pressure to convict.


Professor Hans Köchler, who attended the trial as an official UN observer, said it was tainted by international power politics. Jim Swire, a spokesman for the victims’ families who lost his daughter in the bombing, said he believed Megrahi was innocent, commenting: “Those who have studied (the trial) really find it impossible to maintain faith in the verdict.” Even Lord Fraser of Carmyllie, the Scottish lord advocate who indicted Megrahi, cast doubt on the reliability of the main witness, a Maltese shopkeeper named Tony Gauci. But MacLean, the last survivor of the three-judge panel, never expressed any second thoughts — not even within the privacy of his family. “I have no doubt, on the evidence we heard, that the judgments we made and the verdicts we reached were correct,” he insisted.

Friday, 23 October 2026

Lockerbie accused loses bid to have case thrown out for illegal rendition to US

[What follows is excerpted from a report published yesterday on the BBC News website:]

A Libyan man accused of building the bomb that brought down an American airliner over Lockerbie nearly 38 years ago has lost his bid to have the case thrown out of court.

Abu Agila Mas'ud al-Marimi had claimed he was the victim of an illegal rendition when he was transferred into US custody from Libya in 2022.

A US district court judge has ruled that the manner of his removal should not prevent his trial going ahead in Washington in January.

Marimi has denied playing a key role in the attack on Pan Am 103, which killed 270 people on 21 December 1988.

His attempt to have the case dismissed was made public through documents lodged with the court in Washington.

Marimi's lawyers said he was violently abducted from his home in Tripoli in 2022 by armed members of a militia, "in a cloak and dagger operation conducted in the middle of the night".

They alleged that weeks later, after being held without access to lawyers in a detention centre, he was handed over to FBI agents at an airport in Misrata and flown to the United States.

Marimi argued the case should be dismissed because the United States had invaded his constitutional rights and violated extradition agreements between the US and Libya.

Court transcripts obtained by BBC Scotland News have revealed that trial judge Dabney Friedrich rejected the defence motion.

She referred to a longstanding American legal doctrine, which stipulates that a court's right to hold a trial is not impaired if the suspect has been the subject of a forceful abduction.

"This rule rests on the principle that due process of law is satisfied when one present in court is convicted of a crime after a fair trial and in accordance with constitutional procedural safeguards," said the judge.

"Put differently, there's nothing in the Constitution that requires a court to permit a guilty person rightfully convicted to escape justice because he was brought to trial against his will."

In her ruling, the judge said there were two exceptions to that doctrine.

One would apply if Marimi had been brought before the court through the US government's "deliberate, unnecessary and unreasonable invasion" of his constitutional rights.

For that exception to be triggered, the challenged conduct had to be carried out by, or at the direction of, US officials.

The judge said Marimi's allegations "at best suggest that US government officials exerted pressure on Libyan officials to facilitate a rendition, not that US government officials directed or controlled the challenged conduct."

The second exception to the doctrine would apply if the US government had violated an extradition agreement which was the only way a suspect could be transferred between the two countries.

The judge said the US government had invoked two conventions to secure Marimi's appearance in a US court.

"Neither the Montreal Convention nor the Terrorist Bombings Convention provides that it is the only way by which one country may gain custody of a national of another country for the purposes of prosecution," she said.

"Accordingly, Libya was free to transfer Mr Al-Marimi to the United States using any method it chose."

The defence and prosecution have fought a series of legal battles in the approach to Marimi's trial, which is now scheduled to get underway on 19 January after three postponements.

In another ruling, the judge rejected a defence motion to suppress a confession alleged to have been made by Marimi when he was in custody in Libya in 2012.

According to the FBI, Marimi admitted building the bomb which destroyed Pan Am 103 in an operation carried out by the Libyan intelligence service.

Marimi has claimed the confession was false and was made under duress. (...)

Monday, 28 September 2026

Lockerbie bombing trial will factor in Ramadan for witness testimony

[This is the headline over a report published late yesterday on the website of the United Arab Emirates newspaper The National. It reads in part:]

Plans for the long-awaited trial of alleged Lockerbie bomb maker Abu Agila Mohammad Masud Al Marimi have taken Ramadan, forecast to start on February 7, into account. (...)

Of the 270 victims, 190 were US citizens. The US government filed charges against Mr Al Marimi in 2020 and arrested him in 2022. He pleaded not guilty in 2023.

The suspect's health problems, defence team changes, long pre-trial deliberations and the introduction of several pieces of new evidence have delayed the trial.

Washington District Judge Dabney Friedrich recently set a goal of starting jury selection for the trial in January 2027.

According to a recently filed joint status update for the trial, the Muslim fasting month of Ramadan could affect the start of it. (...)

"The government requests a January 11 [2027] trial date. The parties have noted that Ramadan is likely to begin February 7, 2027," the status update reads in part.

"Several of the government witnesses observe Ramadan. If witness testimony begins on or about January 19, that will allow three weeks for the government to present any witnesses where Ramadan might affect their availability.

"If jury selection is shifted until January 19, 2027, witness testimony may not even begin until January 25, 2027, which only allows 10 days before the start of Ramadan."

Another recently filed document from US federal prosecutors sheds light on one of many witnesses the government plans to use to make its case against Mr Al Marimi.

"As part of its case-in-chief, the government expects to call Alison Pargeter, an expert in Libyan history," the filing reads.

It mentions arguments over what testimony from Ms Pargeter, author of Libya: The Rise and Fall of Qaddafi [published in 2012], will ultimately be heard by a jury.

In August, proposed jury instructions for the trial seen by The National show that both the prosecution and defence teams are concerned about online prediction and betting markets affecting the case.

"You may have heard of online betting markets, prediction markets, or similar platforms where people can place bets or wagers on the outcome of events, including the outcome of court cases and trials," reads the proposed jury instructions agreed to by the defence and prosecution.

About 150 pieces of crash evidence will be presented, along with accounts of witnesses from several countries. Evidence will also come in the form of passports, hotel records, receipts, telegrams, baggage tags and letters.

Many of those documents come from Libya, the UK, the US, Malta, and what was then known as Czechoslovakia. (...)

Tuesday, 15 September 2026

Evidence from victims' relatives "could cause high risk of prejudice"

[What follows is the text of an Associated Press news agency report published today:]

A trial in the US for a former Libyan intelligence official charged in the 1988 bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Scotland is on track to start in January after a delay caused by the discovery of new evidence in the decades-old case.

A federal judge presiding over the case against Abu Agila Mohammad Mas’ud Kheir Al-Marimi is eyeing Jan 19 for the start of jury selection in Washington, DC.

Al-Marimi’s trial had been scheduled to start on Aug 26, but US District Judge Dabney Friedrich postponed it to give defense attorneys more time to examine the newly discovered evidence. The judge said she wants to check on the availability of prospective jurors before locking in a new trial date.

Court filings haven’t specified the nature of the new evidence; the judge and attorneys took pains not to disclose any details during a pretrial hearing on Tuesday [today].

Flight 103 was 31,000 feet (9.45 kilometers) over Lockerbie, Scotland, when a bomb in the New York-bound plane’s forward cargo area exploded 38 minutes after takeoff from London Heathrow Airport on Dec 21, 1988. The blast killed all 259 passengers and crew members and 11 people on the ground in Lockerbie.

Al-Marimi is charged with making the bomb that downed the airplane. Prosecutors allege he and others carried out the bombing at the direction of Libyan leader Moammar Gadhafi, who was ousted and killed during a 2011 civil war.

[A report published today on the BBC News website reads in part:]

The bombing of an American airliner over Lockerbie 37 years ago was intended to inflict "pain and horror," a judge has been told.

The US government made the claim as it argued that relatives of the victims should be allowed to give evidence during the trial of a Libyan suspect.

Prosecutors believe their testimony will help the jury understand the impact of the attack, which killed 270 people on December 21, 1988.

They made the request during the latest hearing on the long-delayed case at the District Court for the District of Columbia in Washington DC.

The man facing trial, Abu Agila Mohammad Masud Kheir Al-Marimi, was handed over to FBI agents in Libya in 2022 and has been in US custody for nearly four years.

He has denied building and priming the bomb which brought down the plane.

Assistant US attorney Brittany Keil told the court: "The purpose of the plan was to inflict pain and horror that would be reported around the world."

Judge Dabney Friedrich has not ruled on whether relatives of victims should be called as witnesses, but expressed concern that it could cause a high risk of prejudice against Al-Marimi. (...)

After two postponements, Al-Marimi was due to stand trial at the end of last month but the case was called off at the last minute after new evidence came to light.

Judge Friedrich agreed to give the defence more time to consider the fresh information, which has not been made public. (...)

Now in his mid-70s, Al-Marimi was in court for the hearing and listened impassively to proceedings through an interpreter.

Defence lawyer Laura Koenig said they will need to question new witnesses and present additional expert testimony in response to the new evidence.

The BBC understands that it is alleged to strengthen the prosecution case against Al-Marimi.

Tuesday, 1 September 2026

US ‘confident’ postponed Lockerbie bombing trial will go ahead in new year

[This is the headline over a PA News Agency report as published tonight on the Enfield Independent website. It reads in part:]

US officials have expressed confidence that the trial of a Libyan man accused of making the bomb that blew up Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie in 1988 will “successfully” go ahead in the new year after a recent postponement caused concern among campaigners.

The federal prosecution of Abu Agila Masud over the deadliest terrorist attack in UK history is now due to get under way on January 11 in Washington DC after the judge ordered a delay last week, citing the disclosure of new evidence that defence lawyers wanted to examine.

The last-minute hold-up, just as jury selection was set to begin, sparked consternation within the Victims of Pan Am Flight 103 group, given the elderly age of many bereaved relatives.

A spokesman for the US Department of Justice said: “It is not unusual for trials to be continued, and the government is confident that this case will go forward at the new trial date successfully.”

However, a hearing due to be held into the status of the postponed case on Tuesday [1 September] was itself delayed until September 15.

Court documents said this was due to “the complex nature of the case, the amount of time required to adequately prepare for pretrial proceedings and for trial… the voluminous discovery, including newly discovered evidence, as well as evidence located in other countries… and the need for the defence to determine how best to defend this case”.

As such it was concluded the “ends of justice… outweigh the best interest of the public and the defendant in a speedy trial”.

The nature of the newly discovered evidence has not been revealed.

Masud’s legal team say the disclosure was made at short notice and that their “constitutional and ethical obligations require the defence to investigate this development”.

The defendant, now in his mid-70s, is charged with two counts of destruction of an aircraft resulting in death.

He faces a maximum penalty of life in prison if convicted. 

Prosecutors claim he once confessed to his role, although this has been challenged by his lawyers.

Masud, who was extradited from Libya to the US in 2022, has denied the charges. (...)

[RB: Masud was not extradited. He was abducted from his home by a LIbyan armed gang, handed over (probably sold) to US government agents and transferred by them without lawful Libyan authority to the United States.] 

Tuesday, 25 August 2026

US Lockerbie bombing trial postponed days before it was due to start

[What follows is excerpted from a report published today on the BBC News website:]

The trial of a Libyan man over the Lockerbie bombing has been postponed for a third time, after new evidence on the 37-year-old case came to light three days ago.

Jury selection was due to get under way in Washington DC on Wednesday but the BBC understands a new start date has been set for January next year.

Lawyers acting for Abu Agila Mohammad [Masud] Kheir Al-Marimi said "newly discovered evidence" previously unknown to the defence and prosecutors from the US government emerged on Friday 21 August.

Al-Marimi has denied building the bomb that destroyed Pan Am Flight 103 on December 21, 1988, killing 270 people.

His lawyers told the court: "Constitutional and ethical obligations require the defence to investigate this development."

They said they met Al-Marimi on Sunday and he agreed that they should ask for the postponement.

The trial judge, Dabney Friedrich, has agreed that the start date should be set aside, underlining the potential importance of the new evidence.

She would have been extremely reluctant to allow an 11th hour postponement after months of preparation and marathon pre-trial legal battles.

For the relatives of those who died and Al-Marimi himself, this latest delay means a verdict might not come until next spring.

It is yet another stunning development in a saga that has witnessed countless twists and turns over nearly four decades. (...)

Al-Marimi has been in US custody since 2022 and was originally due to stand trial in May 2025.

That date was set aside following a joint request from the prosecution and defence, who cited the complexity of the case and Al-Marimi's ill health.

The trial was pencilled in for April this year but was called off again, after the defence asked for more time to prepare.

The Lockerbie bombing has been the subject of a joint Scottish-US investigation since December 1988.

Prosecutors from the Crown Office and detectives from Police Scotland were due to travel to Washington to attend the case, and Scottish witnesses were expected to be among the first to give evidence at the trial.

Laura Buchan, head of the Lockerbie investigation team at the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service said: "I recognise that this adjournment will be disappointing for the families and for those who have followed this case over many years.

"As the matter remains before the court, it would not be appropriate to comment on the reasons for the adjournment. Although these proceedings are being led by the United States authorities, Scottish prosecutors and police officers remain fully committed to supporting the pursuit of justice." (...)

The US government says Al-Marimi admitted bombing the plane along with Megrahi and Fhimah when he was questioned in a Libyan detention facility in 2012.

The alleged confession was handed to Scottish investigators in 2017 and is now central to the prosecution case.

Al-Marimi has claimed the confession is false and was made under duress, but judge Friedrich ruled it can be admitted as evidence at the trial.

[RB: What follows is a reaction from the Rev'd John Mosey, as reported this afternoon on the ITV News website:]

John Mosey, whose 19-year-old daughter Helga died in the Lockerbie attack, told ITV News he had suspicions that it wouldn't go ahead.

Reacting to this morning's postponement, he said: "Not at all surprised, in fact I'd have been surprised if it hadn't been postponed.

"I think there is something going on. This has now been postponed for has it been two, three years? And one has to ask ones self, why? And in this case they say it's new evidence.

"I can't take it seriously, or we're finding it very difficult to take it seriously, but we are trying. Because of how much it's been postponed, and because of the dishonesty and jiggery pokery that's been going on since the first trial and right through."

Asked if he thinks the trial will ever go ahead, he added: "I think they are hoping that this gentleman will pass away and they won't have to produce any evidence. Close the book. Close the case, and that's it. That's my feeling, I may be wrong of course."

Sunday, 23 August 2026

The origin of the Lockerbie bomb

[This is the headline over a letter from Dr Jim Swire published in today's edition of The Sunday Times of Malta, following an article in last Sunday's edition of the newspaper. The letter reads as follows:]

After all these years of attempting to discover the truth about the murder of my daughter, Flora and all those 269 others, our group UK Families-Flight 103 have researched the allegations in depth. That search has always and only been for truth.

If there is one aspect of the tragedy about which we are certain, it is that the Lockerbie bomb did not start its journey from Malta.

There seems no robust evidence to show that it did do so, other than the bought ‘evidence’ given by Tony Gauci concerning the buying of clothes from Mary’s House in Sliema and the discovery of a fragment of circuit board produced in the Zeist court from within a Scots police evidence bag.

It is clear that the fragment of circuit board, which was labelled PT35b in the Zeist court, was planted false evidence. It has been repeatedly carefully analysed in the UK by a series of responsible and academic authorities. These analyses showed that the copper tracks on PT35b had been plated with pure tin, not the alloy of tin and lead which was in universal professional use in 1988.

In addition, a series of trial explosions were conducted for the Zeist defence team by a UK based explosives expert of many years standing which found that the circuit board of the bomb would have been reduced to a brown powder by the blast and heat of the IED bomb. PT35b simply could not be genuine, yet, it was said in America to be the one thing that enabled the Zeist trial to be set up.

The court chose both to ignore these findings and failed to explore how a clearly false item could have entered an official Scots police evidence bag. 

If PT35b had been genuine, it would have proved that a digital electronic timer had been used. The flight time from Luqa to Frankfurt is around two hours and 45 minutes and digital timers like that from which PT35b was alleged to have come can be user settable and encompass delays of many hours. Our work shows that an analogue timing circuit with a maximum run time of around 45 minutes was what really triggered the bomb, so no one could have sent it on its way from Luqa without it exploding over the Mediterranean or continental Europe.

We hope that some aspect of truth may emerge from the upcoming trial of the Libyan Masud but there is no way that that trial can be made to bridge this two hours and 45 minutes between your lovely island and the now peaceful fields surrounding the little town of Lockerbie.

Wednesday, 19 August 2026

"You proceed at your own peril" judge tells "slippery" prosecutors

[What follows is excerpted from a report published today on the website of the United Arab Emirates newspaper The National:]

The long-awaited trial of alleged Pan Am Lockerbie bomb maker Abu Agila Mohammad Masud is weeks away, but the US judge in the case issued a warning to prosecutors on Wednesday over evidence concerns.

During the pre-trial hearing, Washington District Judge Dabney Friedrich told lawyers making the case against Mr Masud that she was concerned they didn't seem to be working hard to ensure that all evidence presented in the case is properly certified and notarised.

"You proceed at your own peril," she told prosecutor Erik Kenerson, who argued that the Pan Am bombing had taken place 38 years ago and evidence had come from several countries, complicating the process of authenticating documents.

[Judge] Friedrich told Mr Kenerson that she understood the complications, but added that she felt US prosecutors have had ample time to ensure evidence is certified. She also said that in the event that Mr Masud were to be found guilty, failure to properly authenticate evidence before the trial would open the case up to an appeal.

Mr Masud, who sat silently in court during the exchange, is accused of making the bomb that brought down Pan Am flight 103 over the Scottish town of Lockerbie in 1988. (...)

"It's like you're not telling me something," she told Mr Kenerson.

The prosecutor replied that "this is a unique case".

"All the more reason for you to dot your Is and cross your Ts," [Judge] Friedrich said.

Roughly 150 pieces of crash evidence will be presented, along with witness accounts from several countries. Evidence will also come in the form of documents such as passports, hotel records, receipts, telegrams, baggage tags and letters. Many of those documents, as US prosecutors also indicated in court, come from Libya, the UK, the US, Malta, and what was known at the time as Czechoslovakia.

Later, [Judge] Friedrich told Conor Mulroe, another prosecutor, that she felt his team was trying to be "slippery" with how they introduced evidence.

"Your honour, if you perceive the government as being slippery or sliding then I apologise for that because we strive every day to advance arguments in good faith that we believe are supported by the law, and we believe are consistent with each other,” Mr Mulroe replied. (...)

Jury selection for Mr Masud's trial is scheduled for August 25, though it could be pushed back in the event that pre-trial deliberations go longer than expected.

Sunday, 16 August 2026

Senior Maltese figures deny Malta link to Lockerbie bomb

[What follows is excerpted from a report published in today's edition of The Times of Malta:]

A popular Netflix series about the Lockerbie bombing presents Malta as the starting point of the bomb’s journey, a version of events long disputed by senior Maltese figures as well as some families of the deceased.

The Bombing of Pan Am 103, which is currently the most-watched show on Netflix in Malta and ranks third globally, broadly follows the case presented by Scottish prosecutors.

But that account was disputed by several figures, including certain investigators, former prime minister Eddie Fenech Adami and former president George Vella. 

The series, first released in the UK last year, follows the joint Scottish and FBI investigation into the bombing of Pan Am flight 103. (...)

Malta features prominently in the series as the Luqa airport is depicted as the place where the Libyan secret service planted a timer bomb in checked-in luggage.

According to the prosecution case, the luggage was transferred to Frankfurt on an Air Malta flight before travelling to London Heathrow and eventually being loaded onto Pan Am 103. (...)

Fenech Adami later questioned whether the bomb could have travelled along the route presented by prosecutors.

In his 2014 book, Eddie – My Journey, he wrote: “My opinion is that it was technically impossible for the bomb to have taken such a complicated route.

“It would also have been a very haphazard method of executing this act of terrorism.”

Alongside many others, the doubts centred on Tony Gauci, a Maltese shopkeeper whose testimony became an important part of the prosecution case. 

Investigators traced clothing found in the suitcase containing the bomb to Mary’s House, a shop in Sliema owned by Gauci.

Gauci identified al-Megrahi as the man who had bought the clothes in December 1988, weeks before the bombing.

Fenech Adami later described him as an unreliable witness.

“The only evidence against al-Megrahi was the testimony of a Maltese shopkeeper, Tony Gauci, who said he sold the Libyan the clothing,” he wrote.

“While I do not think it can be ruled out that al-Megrahi was in some way involved, I have always considered Gauci, who was paid by the Americans, to be a very unreliable witness.”

Vella, who was foreign minister in the 1990s and, again, in the early 2010s, went further.

He told an episode of Times Talk in 2013 that he was convinced al-Megrahi was innocent.

Questions were also raised about Gauci by the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission, an independent body which examines possible miscarriages of justice.

The commission described him as an unreliable witness and said prosecutors had failed to disclose statements to al-Megrahi’s defence showing that Gauci had changed his account on important details over the years.

Al-Megrahi’s defence contended that Gauci was paid “in excess of $2 million” and his brother was paid “in excess of $1m” for their cooperation.

Jim Swire, whose daughter Flora was killed in the bombing, also accused Gauci of “betraying a fellow human being for money” in a Times of Malta interview in 2013.

Documents published later by The Sunday Times of Malta showed that the lead investigator in the case lobbied US authorities to pay at least $3 million to Gauci and his brother Paul for their role in helping secure the conviction. 

Neither brother ever confirmed or denied that they had been paid.

Gauci, who lived in Swieqi before his death in 2016, never spoke publicly about the case.

Joe Mifsud, a former Labour Party official and journalist who is now a magistrate, also challenged the prosecution case in his 2014 book Terror’s Footprints.

“It had always seemed manifestly clear to me that the two accused persons had not committed the terrorist attack and that the suitcase containing the bomb which caused the explosion had not left from Malta.”

Mifsud pointed instead to an argument raised by the defence that the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine – General Command may have been responsible.

The theory is that the Syria-based group received $10 million or so from Iran immediately after Lockerbie. It appeared to have acted as a mercenary or executor in carrying out the wishes of the Iranian Ayatollahs in revenge for the erroneous US downing of an Iranian aircraft in 1988. (...)

Monday, 10 August 2026

US framing Libya to cover up something much darker?

[What follows is excerpted from an article by Martin Jay entitled Lockerbie: Did the CIA itself take down Pan Am 103? published on his Substack today:]

When Western governments used to do highly illegal operations, one of the biggest worries from the outset would always be: what if the press gets hold of this? Scrutiny from journalists for a long time was always the chief worry of the architects of dirty wars, cooperating with terror groups and paying the bad guys.

But since 9/11, the deep state has shifted its views towards media, no longer fearful of its opprobrium.(...)

What is the new relationship [between government and the media]? It is simply that as the internet took off around 2000, media giants realised that their business model of selling newspapers, based on independent journalism which held the state to account, was doomed. The new model to replace it would be to disinvest in journalism as we know it and replace it with a poorer cousin which not only moved it closer to the deep state – in particular the security services – but made it a content junkie for what the CIA, MI5 and Mossad could feed it. The result today is that if you really want to understand a subject and want to do deep research on it, it is highly unlikely you would go to mainstream media. And yet media giants continue to play an important role in shaping our lives and manufacturing a consent which still has the desired effect: keeping the elites in power. We have never seen a period since the invention of newspapers in the 17th century where there is a greater divide between the truth and the perceived truth – and whereby the latter is winning hands down. (...)

This comes about when the political elite allow the security services and journalists to together create an entirely false narrative which works because everyone wants it to be real. (...)

But when those same storytellers get together and re-write history by presenting to the public new documentation which has arrived under extremely dubious circumstances, then those countries can hardly call themselves democracies any more. Under such a farcical arrangement, justice can never be served – or even seen to be served. 

The Lockerbie case, where a US airliner fell from the sky over a sleepy Scottish town, killing all on board and 11 on the ground due to a bomb being placed on board, is a good example of how far the deep state can twist and corrupt judicial process as a means to an end. Bluntly, the Americans, after almost 40 years, want to frame the Libyans for the act of terrorism, as it helps them cover up a darker, more macabre role that they themselves played in the bombing. And yet, despite initially planting evidence in the original case in the Netherlands which neatly framed two Libyan intelligence officers, there has been no hue and cry about their tawdry handling of the case, which should be a scandal. Now it’s much worse. In recent days we have heard reports of new evidence which the Americans claimed to have found – such as accounts of the chief culprit’s own activities in Malta at that time, Semtex explosives believed to be in his office, and fanciful accounts of timers having an eleven-hour duration. All of this so far has come from new documentation which readers should be very cynical about.

But just very recently, an account from a former Mossad agent who was employed by Pan Am’s insurance company to investigate what really happened has thrown a light on why the Americans are so determined, after all this time, to keep the Libyan case alive. In a recent podcast interview, former Mossad assassin Juval Aviv explains how the CIA, from 1987, were allowing Hezbollah in Beirut to use Pan Am to send their own narcotics to the US and collect revenue from them. Reagan allowed this in exchange for keeping seven US/UK hostages alive. These weekly flights, usually from Beirut to Cyprus, then to London, then to the US, were run by CIA officers and were very lucrative for the Lebanese group.

To this day, media hardly touch on the point of these so-called ‘controlled flights’. Aviv’s three-month investigation in 1989 uncovered all the details, and because Pan Am was a client of his as an investigator, he came to the conclusion quite quickly that the Damascus-based Palestinian group which specialised in downing planes was the culprit, via its chief drug supplier from the Beqaa Valley in Lebanon.

What might have been in his initial report which caused him and his work to be marginalised was the bombshell revelation, also made in the podcast, that it was the Americans themselves who brought down the plane – which explains why, to this day, the Americans are going to extraordinary lengths to feed media with disinformation.

Aviv claims that the CIA knew about the bomb and allowed it to get on the plane so that it would kill three rogue officers who were also on the flight, planning to blow the whistle on the drug-running operation to Congress when they got back. Perhaps even more shocking is his claim that over 40 US government workers were ordered off the flight shortly before it departed, and that the drug money made in the US actually went towards buying arms for the Contras. In short, the CIA discovered the bomb plot and allowed it to go ahead so that their operations could not face the embarrassing ignominy which eventually happened to Reagan through the Contra scandal that followed. But besides all this, we have the most recent “evidence” which is being passed off as legitimate: a Libyan security agent’s testimony – secured through torture – being given the green light by a US judge. Nearly 40 years later, the statute of limitations against those accused is not replicated towards US prosecutors, it would seem, who are able to produce fake documents and blood-soaked sworn testimonies which put the Libyans in the frame. If you’ve ever wondered why Hollywood won’t make the movie of Lockerbie, it’s because Americans wouldn’t believe the real story.

Friday, 7 August 2026

Judge allows Lockerbie suspect's alleged confession to be used at US trial

[This is the headline over a report published today on the BBC News website. It reads in part:]

An alleged confession by a suspect in the Lockerbie bombing will be allowed as evidence in a trial in the United States, a judge has ruled.

Lawyers for Abu Agila Mas'ud Kheir Al-Marimi had asked for the contested statement to be ruled inadmissible, claiming it was false and made under duress.

But the document will now form a central part of the prosecution case when the postponed trial begins at a federal court in Washington DC later this month.

Libyan Al-Marimi, also known as Masud, has denied making and priming the bomb that destroyed Pan Am Flight 103 over Dumfries and Galloway on 21 December 1988. (...)

A group representing relatives of American victims of the atrocity described judge's decision as outcome as "another step in our long fight for justice".

The existence of Al-Marimi's alleged confession was first revealed in 2020 when the US government announced it was charging him over the bombing.

An FBI criminal complaint said he had freely admitted his involvement when he was questioned by a police officer in a Libyan detention facility in 2012.

Al-Marimi is said to have told the officer he acted alongside fellow members of the Libyan intelligence service, under the orders of senior officials.

According to the officer's account, Al-Marimi said he transported the bomb hidden in a suitcase from Libya to Malta, where he met two accomplices.

One was Abdulbasset Al Megrahi, the Libyan agent convicted of playing a central role in the plot at the first Lockerbie trial 25 years ago.

The second was said to be Al Amin Khalifa Fhimah, a former Libyan Arab Airline official who was cleared by the same Scottish court.

The officer said Al-Marimi admitted setting the bomb timer so the explosion would occur 11 hours later, before handing the suitcase to Fhimah at Malta's Luqa airport.

Fhimah placed it onto a conveyor belt, introducing the unaccompanied bag into the international baggage system, tagged to be flown to the US.

Later that night, at 31,000 ft, it exploded in the forward hold of Pan Am 103.

Al-Marimi is alleged to have claimed he was later congratulated in person by the late Libyan dictator Colonel Gaddafi, for carrying out "a great national duty" against the Americans.

The Washington court has heard that the Libyan police officer - referred to as Jamal - kept a handwritten document containing the confession and a carbon copy of the statement in a safe in his home.

In 2015, he handed them over to the Libyan Attorney General's Office, who gave a copy of the confession to prosecutors from Scotland's Crown Office two years later. They shared it with the Americans.

The team of public defenders representing Al-Marimi at the District [Court] of the District of Columbia asked for the alleged confession to be excluded from his trial.

Jamal gave evidence in person at a hearing in the United States as judge Dabney Friedrich considered whether the statement should be allowed as evidence.

Prosecutors argued its highly-detailed contents could be corroborated to an extent unlikely with a fabricated confession.

At one point, Judge Friedrich instructed the US government to get hold of the original handwritten document and the carbon copy, only to be told the authorities in Tripoli couldn't find them.

Jamal now looks likely to be called as a witness at the trial, giving the jury the chance to hear his testimony for themselves, and the defence an opportunity to challenge his version of events.

A statement released by the Victims of Pan Am Flight 103 said: "We are pleased with today's ruling.

"While we have always trusted the [US] government had a strong case, this only reinforces it.

"We look forward to gaining more information about the truth of what happened... this is another step in our long fight for justice.

"Jamal's courage to come forward with this confession and his testimony during the motion to suppress hearing does not go unnoticed by family members."

[RB: Victims of Pan Am Flight 103 is a US organisation. The UK equivalent is UK Families Flight 103. I wonder if their reaction was sought by the BBC.]

Wednesday, 5 August 2026

Netflix "The Bombing of Pan Am 103": Incomplete, one-sided portrayal

[What follows is excerpted from an article by Patrick Huber published today on the Austrian Wings website:]

In a six-part miniseries, the US film giant Netflix dramatized the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 on December 21, 1988. Despite its high level of detail, the series ultimately disappoints with a one-sided portrayal of the perpetrators, a perspective that is objectively untenable, argues Patrick Huber, a long-time contributor to Austrian Wings, in his recent commentary. Huber has been researching the topic for over 20 years and published the first German-language book on the subject in December 2023, titled Pan Am Flight 103: The Tragedy of Lockerbie - A Christmas Journey to Death.

The facts of the Lockerbie disaster (Pan Am Flight 103) in brief. A bomb exploded in the cargo hold of Pan Am's Boeing 747-121, N739PA, Clipper Maid of the Seas, which was scheduled to fly as PA 103 from London Heathrow to New York JFK on December 21, 1988. The aircraft broke apart in mid-air and crashed into the Scottish town of Lockerbie. The 243 passengers, 2 pilots (captain and first officer), 1 flight engineer, and 13 flight attendants on board the Pan Am jumbo jet died, as did 11 residents of the Lockerbie community. Many children were among the victims; entire families were wiped out.

The question of who was responsible for the bomb was never definitively answered. A trial under Scottish law in the Netherlands in 2001 led to the conviction of a suspected Libyan secret agent – ​​a verdict that remains highly controversial in expert circles. However, experts (including legal scholars and UN trial observer Professor Hans Köchler, whose reports can be found here ) and many relatives of the victims considered it a miscarriage of justice and are convinced of the alleged perpetrator's innocence. Professor Köchler, who contacted me by email on August 6. 2026, after the publication of this commentary, pointed out that he had always consideredEl-Megrahi "not guilty as charged."

Professor Köchler literally wrote in a statement dated August 23, 2003 that can be read online here: "It is highly likely that the convicted Libyan national is not guilty as charged and that one or more countries other than Libya, through their intelligence services and/or financial and logistical support for a terrorist group, may have responsibility for the crime. In this regard, last year's revelations by Atef Abu Baker of the Fateh Revolutionary Council (made public after the assassination of Abu Nidal in Baghdad) will have to be further investigated. Since the events of September 11, 2001, there is absolutely no excuse for not fully investigating the responsibility for the Lockerbie crime. Terrorism cannot be fought through a political deal aimed at covering up the truth, but must be eradicated through identification and punishment of all countries, individuals and organizations that may have had responsibility for a specific terrorist act." 

I also recommend my commentary from October 2025, "Commentary on the Lockerbie Bombing - Who Bombed Pan Am Flight 103?" . Two years earlier, shortly before the 35th anniversary of the disaster, my book Pan Am Flight 103: The Lockerbie Tragedy - A Christmas Journey to Death, published after years of research , examines the attack and all open and already resolved questions in minute detail. (...)

When I heard about the new six-part Netflix series The Bombing of Pan Am 103, I decided to watch it. After decades of studying this tragedy, I was eager to see it. It's not a documentary, of course, and some elements have been altered for dramatic effect, but it's fundamentally very well-researched. Even little-known facts are addressed, and the seat numbers of individual passengers are accurately depicted.

While the first five parts are consistently worth watching, the final part is a huge disappointment and ruins everything. It deals with the trial of the two Libyan defendants, which ultimately ended with Abdel Bassit Ali Mohammed el Megrahi being convicted, while his co-defendant was acquitted.

The series concludes with this, usually leaving viewers with the (completely false) impression that the case is (largely) solved – but in reality, it is far from that. The series makes no mention whatsoever of the fact that not only (as mentioned at the beginning) numerous (primarily British) relatives of the victims doubt El-Megrahi's guilt, but also that both UN trial observer Hans Köchler and Scottish law professor Robert Black criticized the verdict as a "miscarriage of justice" that stigmatized an innocent man and deprived him of his freedom. In an interview with "The Scotsman" on November 1, 2005, Professor Black described El-Megrahi's conviction as "the most shameful miscarriage of justice in Scotland in 100 years."

The Netflix series instead adopts the decidedly "convenient" narrative for the US and UK of the convicted Libyan (lone) perpetrator and presents it to the viewer as "the whole truth." But it is, at best, only a part of the story, by no means the whole picture. A great deal is missing.

For although Libya's (and its intelligence agents') complicity in the attack on Pan Am 103 cannot be ruled out and is quite possible, there were and are leads pointing to Iran, more precisely the Islamic Republic of Iran (established in 1979), to Syria, and to the Palestinian territories of the Middle East. The evidence against Iran was particularly strong. However, the Netflix series largely ignores these facts, not even in the end credits. There are only a few tentative hints. To me, they seem like a tiresome "obligatory exercise" by the creators, along the lines of: check item, next scene.

From a legal standpoint, it doesn't have to depict everything (it's a series, not a documentary or academic work), but this one-sided portrayal, on the one hand, simply doesn't correspond to the known facts, and on the other hand, it's a slap in the face to the relatives of the 270 victims, who, after almost 40 years of uncertainty, finally deserve a definitive answer to the question of who was responsible for the deaths of their loved ones. A lone perpetrator—whether El-Megrahi or anyone else—could absolutely not have been responsible, as the UN trial observer clearly stated over 20 years ago. A single perpetrator could never have managed the incredible logistical effort of such a terrorist operation; even two or three perpetrators would have been insufficient. According to UN trial observer Köchler, at least "a dozen" participants would have been needed. It's quite possible that it was some kind of terrorist cooperation between Iran, Libya, Syria, and the Palestinians. It's also not out of the question that the convicted El-Megrahi might have been involved in some way. However, the evidence was simply insufficient for a conviction according to modern legal standards – and that's a crucial point. Because in a modern legal process, the principle of "in dubio pro reo" (presumption of innocence) must always apply. The evidence in El-Megrahi's conviction was extremely weak, leaving many questions unanswered. Or, to quote the UN trial observer, university professor Hans Köchler: "If someone had submitted this verdict as a seminar paper to me, it would have received a clear failing grade for inconsistency of argumentation." Ouch. That stings. (...)

Netflix also omits the fact that Dr Jim Swire (whose daughter Flora was killed in the attack on Pan Am 103) was also convinced of El-Megrahi's innocence, and that a friendship even developed between the two men. Dr. Swire doesn't appear at all (or only so briefly and insignificantly that I must have missed it), even though he made a crucial contribution to improving security measures in the aftermath of the disaster. (...)

If I had to grade the Netflix series "The Bombing of Pan Am 103" using the school grading system, my personal verdict would be, at best, a "Sufficient," and even that only because the first five episodes are solid and well-produced. If I were to evaluate only the sixth episode, my rating would be a clear "Fail."

For anyone interested in this complex case, I have two link recommendations here – in addition to my own book :

The Lockerbie Case (Blog by Professor Robert Black, Scotland)

The video documentary The Maltese Double Cross  by American filmmaker Allan Francovich (d. 1997); public screenings of the film were heavily restricted by Great Britain and the USA, which is why it did not achieve widespread distribution; it has never been publicly shown in the USA.

Thus, every reader can form their own opinion on this matter and how they personally categorize the Netflix series The Bombing of Pan Am 103.

Thursday, 30 July 2026

Lockerbie trial brings fresh scrutiny of evidence against Libyan suspect

[This is the headline over an article published yesterday in Libya Review. It reads as follows:]

The upcoming US trial of Libyan national Abu Agila Masud al-Marimi is renewing debate over the evidence surrounding the 1988 Lockerbie bombing, including claims that Iran, rather than Libya, was responsible for the attack.

A BBC report reviewed competing accounts as proceedings against al-Marimi are expected to resume in Washington in August. Al-Marimi has denied involvement in the bombing of Pan Am Flight 103, while questions over the original investigation have remained contentious in Libya and abroad.

One prominent alternative theory has been advanced by Jim Swire, whose daughter Flora was killed in the bombing. Swire has maintained that Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, the Libyan convicted in the case, was wrongly convicted and has argued that Iran was behind the attack.

The theory partly rests on the bombing of an Iranian passenger aircraft by a US warship five months earlier, which killed 290 people, followed by Iranian threats of retaliation.

Former CIA officer John Holt has also questioned the official account and previously argued that investigators should examine Iran and the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine-General Command. Libya Review has reported Holt’s claims that intelligence material pointing towards Libyan involvement was unreliable.

The credibility of former Libyan intelligence officer Abdul-Majid Giaka has also come under scrutiny. Holt has alleged that Giaka provided fabricated information to the CIA, while parts of his testimony were previously challenged during the Lockerbie proceedings.

Leaked Libyan intelligence documents have added another layer to the debate. Investigative journalist Vincent Nouzille said some documents contain details concerning al-Megrahi and al-Marimi and appear to match information supplied by Giaka. However, the available documents are copies rather than originals, limiting their forensic value.

Al-Marimi was transferred to US custody in 2022 and has consistently denied the allegations. His defence has also raised concerns over missing evidence, including an interrogation recording allegedly linked to his purported confession.

The case could therefore place the original Lockerbie evidence under renewed scrutiny while reopening long-standing questions over Libya’s alleged role in the bombing.

Wednesday, 15 July 2026

BBC Scotland revisits Lockerbie bombing

[What follows is the text of an item published today on The Highland Times website:]

One of Scotland’s most enduring and controversial criminal investigations is returning to the spotlight in a new BBC Scotland podcast series examining fresh evidence surrounding the Lockerbie bombing.

The six part series, Lockerbie, follows journalist Myles Bonnar as he revisits the investigation into the destruction of Pan Am Flight 103, which claimed the lives of 270 people in December 1988.

The series launches at a significant moment, with alleged bomb maker Abu Agila Masud due to stand trial in Washington DC.

Masud denies the allegations against him, while American prosecutors believe the trial could reveal new details about how the bombing was planned and carried out.

Produced by BBC Scotland for Radio 4’s Intrigue strand and BBC Sounds, the series explores the evidence gathered over nearly four decades, while examining why questions and competing theories have continued long after the original conviction.

Abdelbaset al Megrahi remains the only person convicted of the bombing, although he maintained his innocence until his death in 2012 and doubts surrounding the investigation have persisted ever since.

Throughout the series, Bonnar speaks with Scottish investigators, intelligence officers, journalists, legal experts, campaigners and relatives of those who died in the disaster.

Among those interviewed is Dr Jim Swire, whose daughter Flora was killed in the bombing and who continues to argue that the original investigation reached the wrong conclusion.

The podcast also examines intelligence gathered from a Libyan double agent known as “Puzzle Piece” and explores the so called Senussi Files, documents recovered from the ruins of Libya’s intelligence headquarters following the 2011 uprising.

Those files are said to raise fresh questions about Megrahi and other alleged conspirators.

As the new trial begins in the United States, the series asks whether the latest evidence could finally answer some of the questions that have surrounded the Lockerbie bombing for almost forty years.

Myles Bonnar said: “Lockerbie remains a story filled with questions, extraordinary characters and profound human loss.

“As new developments bring renewed attention to the case, this series explores the evidence, the controversies, and the enduring search for answers.”

Lockerbie will be available on 22 July when all episodes will be made available on BBC Sounds.

[RB: The whole series can be listened to here. It is disappointing how little time is given to the very serious concerns about the Megrahi conviction raised by inter alios Paul Foot, Dr Morag Kerr and John Ashton.]

Wednesday, 6 May 2026

Lockerbie star witness accused of ‘yarns’

[This is the headline over a report published in today's edition of the Daily Mail. It reads in part:]

Lawyers for the Libyan accused of building the Lockerbie bomb have lodged papers claiming a ‘star witness’ for the prosecution is ‘not credible’.

The US government’s case against Abu Agila Mohammad Mas’ud Kheir Al-Marimi is largely based on his alleged confession to his involvement in the atrocity.

But his legal team want the case thrown out on the basis the ‘glacial pace’ of proceedings since he was extradited to the US in 2022 violates his rights.

They also say the ‘ongoing failure’ by his Libyan interrogator to provide original copies, allegedly written on carbon paper, support the call to ‘dismiss’ the charges.

Lawyers acting on behalf of Masud, as he is known, have now lodged papers with the court urging it to find the interrogator, known only as Jamal, ‘not credible’. Their claims centre around the alleged carbon copy provided by Jamal that the prosecution plans to use as evidence at his trial.

They also question why there are ‘underlines’ on the document that Jamal claims he did not make. Masud’s lawyers state that the American government ‘seems unwilling to recognise just how fatal these continued lies are for Jamal’s credibility’.

They add: ‘Perhaps it is because Mr Al-Marimi’s alleged confession was central to the government’s decision to charge Mr Al-Marimi and its prosecution of him that the government does not want to accept that its star witness is spinning yarns.’

Prosecutors say the defence ‘has offered no theory for why the officer would convey what he knew was a falsehood when he stood to gain nothing by doing so.’

But Masud’s legal team claim there are ‘possible reasons Jamal has lied’ including ‘acting at the behest of more powerful figures’, or he ‘thinks he can continue getting away with spinning tales in order to build rapport with a government that has worked to provide him personal benefits’.

Masud, an ex-Libyan intelligence officer, is due to stand trial in Washington DC.

He is alleged to have built the bomb that brought down Pan Am 103 over Lockerbie in 1988. (...)