Monday, 11 April 2011

Libya: Britain told US not to intervene in Lockerbie bomber release

[This is the headline over a report in today's edition of the Daily Telegraph. It reads in part:]

The British ambassador to the US told America it should not intervene to stop the release of the Lockerbie bomber from a Scottish prison, according to leaked diplomatic cables obtained by WikiLeaks and passed to the Daily Telegraph.

Nigel Sheinwald told James Steinberg, the US Deputy Secretary of State, that he was "concerned" that the demands of victims' families were unduly influencing US policy.

His comments came during critical negotiations over whether Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, who was convicted of the murder of 270 passengers on Pan Am Flight 103, should be switched to a Libyan jail to serve the remainder of his sentence.

Sir Nigel was Tony Blair's foreign policy adviser between 2003 and 2007 and played a key role, alongside the Libyan Foreign Minister Moussa Koussa, in bringing Colonel Muammar Gaddafi back into the international fold. He was at Mr Blair's side for the first meeting with Colonel Gaddafi in 2007 that resulted in a substantial BP oil contract. [RB: Sheinwald was at Blair's side throughout the negotiations that resulted in the "deal in the desert".]

The cable, obtained by WikiLeaks and passed to the Daily Telegraph, is dated February 2009. It states: "Sheinwald asked that the US continue to consult with the UK in the possible transfer of ailing Pan Am bomber Abdel-Basset al-Megrahi from the UK to Libya. Specifically, he said HMG supported the discussions this week between UK and US officials to define a common strategy.

"Sheinwald cited concern that the Pan Am victims' families were asking for direct US intervention to stop the transfer. He asked that the United States delay "for a few days" any intervention with the Scottish authorities, who will ultimately decide on the transfer." [RB: At this stage, only repatriation under the UK-Libya prisoner transfer agreement was in issue. No application for compassionate release was made by Megrahi until several months later.]

He was firmly rebuffed by Deputy Secretary Steinberg. The cable states: "The Deputy said the UK government needed to understand the sensitivities in this case, and noted he was acutely aware of the concerns of Lockerbie victim's groups from his previous time in government."

Mr Megrahi was controversially released on compassionate grounds seven months later after being diagnosed with cancer.

Last night the victim's families were furious that British diplomats actively lobbied to stop the US intervening in Megrahi's release.

Kathleen Flynn, whose son John Patrick died in the bombing, said: "It is disgraceful that the British were complicit in his release. This man was a killer who took 270 innocent lives but was allowed go free and live the life of riley in Tripoli."

Sir Nigel Sheinwald also reportedly gave Gaddafi's son, Saif, help with his PhD thesis. The doctorate awarded him by the London School of Economics was already thought suspect because he followed it with a £1.5 million donation. Mr Sheinwald denied the allegation, saying he met Saif Gaddafi while he was writing his thesis but had not helped him. (...)

Senior Labour Cabinet ministers always denied being involved in any backstairs deals over the release in August 2009, yet a secret Foreign Office memo referred to a "game plan" to facilitate Megrahi's move to Libya.

Sir Gus O'Donnell, the cabinet secretary, said in an analysis of the papers: "Once Megrahi had been diagnosed with terminal cancer in September 2008, (government) policy was based upon an assessment that UK interests would be damaged if Megrahi were to die in a UK jail."

A Foreign Office spokesman said: "We do not comment on leaked documents."


  1. MISSION LOCKERBIE, 2011, doc. nr.1237.rtf. (google translation german/english):

    An UK Foreign Office spokesman said: "We do not comment on leaked documents."
    In this way in UK analyz questionings choke abrupt !

    Great Britain will continue to do whatever is necessary to keep the lid firmly on their heinous secrets, whatever their motives were in the "Lockerbie Affair"; including hold back of Mr Moussa Koussa in a safe house before the world wide media for interviews ...

    So the Senators Robert Menendez, Frank Lautenberg, Charles Schumer and Kristen Gillibrand would be well served not only to support their "JUSTICE UNDONE" but also "JUSTICE OF HUMANITY" for Al Megrahi...

    In addition please see and hear what my mutual Facebook friend, Susan Lindauer, has to say about David Cameron's war on Libya.
    Video: Oil War Crimes: 'Libya pays for embarrassing US' :

    by Edwin Bollier MEBO Ltd. Switzerland. URL:

  2. Translation (of the article, not ebol):

    By early 2009, the UK and the US had agreed to create a situation (prisoner transfer) that had a side-effect of forcing al-Megrahi's second appeal into oblivion. The final decision of course, from Scotland, spurned this arrangement, citing the US family members' "understanding" the "bomber" would serve his whole sentence in Scotland.

    The mysterious part is how this release, still tacitly approved by all parties, STILL wound up squashing that potent appeal. Even with no above-the-boards reason for it, the primary expectation was still met.

  3. Followers of this blog may be interested to learn that the terrorist and former CIA operative Luis Carriles Posada was recently acquitted of perjury by a Texas Jury. (His statement to the Immigration authorities was contradicted by an interview he had given to the New York Times.)

    Venezuela continues to seek his extradition in relation to the 1976bombing of Cubanair Flight 455. (I am not aware if Senator Menendez is of the view that Posada should be returned to his Venezuelan prison cell but I assume he regards Posada as a freedom fighter not a terrorist like Mr Al-Megrahi.)