Compassion call in bomber appeal

A “compassionate country” would let the terminally ill Lockerbie bomber return home to Libya AND continue his appeal, according to a retired Scottish law professor.

Responding to a leaked report on Abdelbaset Ali Mohmed Al Megrahi’s psychological state, Professor Robert Black QC said it was a “tragedy” the Libyan could only return home if he abandoned the quest to clear his name.

The confidential medical report, leaked to a Scottish national newspaper, is said to have been written by a consultant clinical psychologist and commissioned by the Libyan consul. It is said to warn that Megrahi is suffering high levels of emotional and psychological distress and highlights the detrimental effect of his social and cultural isolation.

Professor Black, who was born and grew up in Lockerbie and is one of the founders of the Justice for Megrahi campaign, said a reason for the refusal of a bail application last November was that Megrahi would receive the best possible treatment for his cancer in Greenock Prison.

He said: “It is difficult to see how this assurance can be reconciled with the total absence of psychological counseling provided or offered by the prison service. It is unsurprising that, given this, he should now wish to be returned to his own country where he can be supported in his last weeks or months by his family and friends.”

The first stage of Megrahi’s appeal was heard in court in Edinburgh last month. At the same time Libya applied for the return of the bomber to them under the recently ratified Prisoner Transfer Agreement between Libya and the UK. The Scottish Government will rule on the application but could only grant it if Megrahi dropped his appeal.

Professor Black, credited as one of the architects of the original court case at Camp Zeist in Holland, said: “What a civilised country would do is grant him compassionate release (which is within the power of the Scottish Government) to return to Libya while allowing his appeal to proceed.

“But I fear there are too many vested interests which wish the appeal to be aborted and the legitimate concerns over his conviction to be swept under the carpet.”

The Libyan, who was diagnosed with prostate cancer last year, was convicted of the bombing of Pan Am flight 103, which exploded over Lockerbie in December 1988 killing 270 people, in 2001. A first appeal against the conviction was unsuccessful but Megrahi’s case was put forward for a second appeal after the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission found he may have been the victim of a miscarriage of justice.

[This is the text of an article by Carol Hogarth in this week's edition of Lockerbie's local newspaper, the Annandale Herald.]