Friday, 20 December 2013

Lockerbie bombing: Megrahi relatives want to appeal

[This is the headline over a report published this evening on the BBC News website.  It reads as follows:]

The family of Lockerbie bomber Abdelbaset Al-Megrahi has told the BBC they want to appeal against his conviction.

Megrahi died at his home in Tripoli in May last year from terminal cancer. He had always protested his innocence.

His brother Abdel-Hakim Al-Megrahi said the family "wanted the truth to be revealed".

He also said he was hopeful the Libyan government would help to fund the appeal.

In an interview with the BBC's Libya correspondent Rana Jawad, he said: 

"Yes, we want to appeal and we wish for the truth to be revealed and this is not just for our own benefit but also for the benefit of the families of the victims and for public opinion.

"We need to know who committed this horrible crime. But, as you know, we as a family cannot afford to pay for the appeals process.

"God-willing, the Libyan government will do this, but it has to be launched by the family first. As a family, we want to appeal; we want the Lockerbie files to reopen to know who is responsible.

"He said the family were sure the Libyan government would help to fund the appeal because clearing his brother of committing the atrocity would also be "an acquittal for all Libyans and Libya".

"At the moment, it is perhaps difficult for the Libyan government to help us," he added.

"But we hope, and we are very optimistic, that when the government stabilises it will help us because the Lockerbie problem is not an individual or family issue, but rather a Libya problem."

"My brother Abdelbaset could not have committed this heinous crime. He could never hurt any single person, let alone 271 innocent victims".

Abdel-Hakim Al-Megrahi insisted his brother had not been a Libyan intelligence officer, and claimed he had instead been a graduate in aviation engineering who had been employed by Libyan Airlines.

He added: "However, if he was used [as a scapegoat] for this problem [Lockerbie] - it's possible that he was used because the Gaddafi regime used to use any Libyan. In truth Libya was like a farm for Gaddafi and his sons and as Libyan nationals, we were like slaves - we couldn't say "no". We couldn't, this is the truth.

"But I assure you, and with reference to all the universities my brother studied in, be it in the US, Britain and Pakistan - he is a graduate of aviation engineering."

Megrahi was found guilty at a trial in 2001, and jailed for life. His co-accused Al-amin Khalifa Fimah was acquitted.

Dr Jim Swire, whose daughter Flora died when the Pan-Am flight 103 exploded over Lockerbie in 1988, said earlier this week that some families of those who died may seek a fresh appeal against Megrahi's conviction.

Mr Swire believes that Megrahi was wrongfully convicted of the atrocity.

But Scottish and US investigators stand by the evidence presented at his trial and are pursuing other potential suspects.

In a BBC interview on Monday, the Lord Advocate Frank Mulholland said "the conviction stands".

"We were ready to meet the arguments and challenges that Mr Megrahi and his lawyers were placing before the court," he said.

"If there's any further evidence, if anyone's got any concerns about it, they should make it known to the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission."

The 25th anniversary of the bombing, which claimed 270 lives, will be marked in ceremonies in the US and the UK on Saturday. 

[An application to the SCCRC by members of Megrahi's family would have considerably higher chances of avoiding the problems and pitfalls that I mentioned earlier today than an application by relatives of Lockerbie victims.]


  1. I fear this move, coinciding as it does with the latest pronouncements by the Crown Office, police and FBI, is yet another stalling tactic engineered by them and /or the Libyan government. Can you realistically see the Libyans financing an appeal? Effectively however this could stymie any attempt by the Lockerbie relatives to resurrect the appeal. Nothing with Lockerbie is ever as it seems.

  2. MISSION LIFE WITH LOCKERBIE, 2013 -- Go on ground to new facts...

    It had come so !
    In the Name of Allah, the most Compassionate, the most Merciful.

    Many thanks to Al Megrahi relatives.

    by Edwin and Mahnaz Bollier, MEBO Ltd. Webpage:

  3. That's true, Iain. We'll just have to play each ball as it comes.

  4. More sober consideration. Does it make any real difference? We're only talking about an approach to the SCCRC. Two approaches can me made at the same time, I believe. Last time, once Megrahi's own SCCRC investigation was underway, it was open to any interfering busybody to submit material as far as I remember.

  5. My concern is that the possibility of a family appeal, which will take precedence, will delay or even derail a legitimate application from another source. If the family appeal is genuinely based then fine but thereby hangs my scepticism.

  6. I share your scepticism Iain.

    I'm concerned to read quotes from Megrahi's family that they are looking for help from the current Libyan government with their appeal. That worries me.