In
his report on the trial, the official United Nations observer, Professor Hans
Koechler described the finding of only Megrahi being guilty as
‘incomprehensible’.
As Megrahi’s legal team prepared to
attempt to overturn the verdict for a second time, one last, crucial piece of
evidence was finally unearthed — evidence that would almost certainly
have caused the case against him to collapse had it been known at the time of
the original trial.
This evidence was never heard, because
Megrahi was released in August 2009 on compassionate grounds after being
diagnosed with prostate cancer before it was due to be presented in court.
For years, a cornerstone of the
evidence of Libya’s involvement in the Lockerbie outrage — and, therefore, of
Megrahi’s — was that tiny fragment of printed circuit board which had been
found in one of the items of clothing bought from the Gaucis. The Americans had
matched it to a small consignment of timers that had been sold to Libyan
intelligence.
But exhaustive forensic tests carried
out on behalf of Megrahi’s defence team proved in 2009 that although the
fragment of circuit board apparently came from the bomb’s timer, it did not
actually match any of the timers which had been sold to Libyan intelligence.
The Libyans had been supplied with
timers whose copper circuitry was covered in an alloy of lead and tin. But the
circuitry on the fragment from the Lockerbie bomb was covered only in tin.
It is a tiny difference, but a
crucial one. There was now no evidence that the Lockerbie bomb had a Libyan
timer.
In the event, at the original trial the
judges recommended that a man they had sentenced to life imprisonment, a mass
murderer who had killed 270 people, serve a minimum sentence of just 20 years.
Ever since, the Megrahi team has spent years trying — successfully, I believe —
to prove the Libyan was never guilty.
And while as a member of that team I
accept that I may be regarded as party pris, it is surely difficult to avoid
the feeling that the evidence against Megrahi was unreliable and that an
innocent man had been convicted of committing the worst terrorist atrocity in
British history.
c
ReplyDeleteI was interested to learn that my fellow Cumbrian John Ashton lives in Brighton. I went down there last year to secure a vital piece of evidence. He could have saved me the trip!
ReplyDelete